Being Sane is a weekly Sunday newsletter written for my coaching clients and shared as a gentle companion for reflection and self-study. It explores how we relate to work, effort, and ambition, and the small shifts that shape how we show up over time.
Share
🌀Default vs Chosen: Why the Bean Vanilla Has Been Your Ice Cream Order for Years
Published 4 days ago • 5 min read
Hello friends,
Bengaluru has turned properly hot, which gave me all the excuse I needed to make my way to Ibaco, my favourite ice cream parlour, last week. I go there every summer and order the same thing: bean vanilla with rainbow sprinkles and two candied cherries.
But this summer of 2026 was going to be different. I walked in with a firm intention to try something new. I was going to be adventurous with my one precious life.
Ibaco has an absurd number of flavours, most of them requiring a tasting and a conversation with Sarita, the person behind the counter, before you know what you are ordering. Sarita, who knows me well, promptly steered me towards the new summer flavours. I sampled three. All of them interesting. One of them a real find.
Spoilt for choices, every single time!
I could sense a thrill going down my spine.
But when I opened my mouth to order, out came the bean vanilla with rainbow sprinkles and two candied cherries. In a waffle cone instead of a cup.
On the walk home, I chuckled at myself rather ruefully. I went in with full intention, did the work of sampling, found something I liked, and still ordered my standard.
I have been thinking about that walk home ever since. Because I suspect you recognise this moment too. And I suspect it is not only about ice cream.
Enjoy the read!
Siri
The Loop You Cannot See
In the 1993 film Groundhog Day, Phil Connors, a cynical weather reporter, gets trapped in a time loop. He wakes up every morning on the same day, 2nd February, in Punxsutawney, Pennsylvania. Same alarm. Same song. Same faces. Same choices.
​
For a long stretch of the film, he does what most of us would do. He defaults. The loop is invisible to everyone around him. Only Phil knows he is in it.
And for a long time, even knowing he is in it, he cannot get out. Because he does not want to get out.
This is what makes the film such an uncomfortable watch. Not the loop itself. The fact that he knows, and stays anyway. In real life, no one shows us the loop. We just live it. And tell ourselves we are fine with it.
Why the Brain Keeps Ordering the Same Thing
Barry Schwartz, in his work on the paradox of choice, helps explain why awareness alone is not enough to break the loop. The more options we have, the higher the imagined cost of getting it wrong.
Every additional choice raises the possibility of regret, and the brain, whose job is to protect us, responds by retreating to what it already knows. What is safe. What has worked before. What will not require the cognitive effort of genuine evaluation.
This is not a limitation. It is a beautifully efficient piece of engineering.
​
In survival terms, the bean vanilla is always the sensible bet. You do not know if you will like the new custard apple flavour, and what is the point in potentially ruining your limited chances at ice cream this summer?
This is exactly what Phil Connors is up against. The loop is not just external. It is running inside him too. Once he realises he is in it, he spends a long stretch trying to manipulate it: using his knowledge of the repeating day to get what he wants, impress people, avoid consequences. He is working the system rather than genuinely changing.
It is only when he stops trying to extract advantage from the loop and starts acting from a different place inside himself that things shift.
The day does not change. He does.
What This Looks Like in Your Work and Life
When we make familiar or default choices, it is not just about the brain conserving energy. There is an emotional payoff in the decision too.
The payoff is the relief of already knowing how this ends. The familiar role, the known dynamic, the default answer: none of them are exciting, but they are certain. And certainty, even when it costs us, is something the brain will choose over the unknown almost every time.
This is why even with awareness, people cannot leave toxic workplaces, abusive relationships, or change self-sabotaging behaviours. This is why we enact the same mental patterns and thought loops, which once triggered can be hard to break out of.
The default does not show up as fear or avoidance. It presents as practicality. As maturity. As knowing yourself.
I've always been better in structured environments.I'm not really a creative person.Better the devil you know.This is just who I am.
These are not self-knowledge. They are the brain ordering bean vanilla on your behalf, and calling it a preference.
The person who keeps taking late night calls despite the toll on their sleep and mental health. The person who keeps replying to emails over the weekend instead of switching off. The person who replays the idea of quitting instead of taking action to speak up or draw a boundary. Not because it is working, but because it is habit. It is the bean vanilla.
And the brain does not distinguish between low stakes and high stakes. The cost of defaulting at Ibaco is a mildly disappointing walk home. The cost of defaulting on where you work, how you work, what you are willing to ask for, who you are becoming: that accumulates differently. And it does so slowly enough that by the time you notice, the bean vanilla has been your order for years.
The resentment comes later. On the walk home, carrying the waffle cone.
​
To Reflect
This is not about forcing yourself to always choose the unfamiliar. Sometimes the bean vanilla genuinely is what you want. The point is to know the difference: is this a real preference, or is the brain protecting you from the discomfort of choosing?
Three questions worth sitting with:
1. What is your secret intention here that you have been withholding even from yourself? What do you actually want from this decision? Write it in a single sentence, in your own words, before you look at any of the options.
2. What is driving your current preference? Is it the fear of uncertainty, or the relief of familiarity?
3. What are your real options, once you remove the ones the brain pre-eliminated? What is still on the board if you put the conservative filters down, just for a moment?
You do not have to order the custard apple every time. But it is worth making that choice consciously, rather than letting your brain make it for you while you are distracted by Ibaco's chalkboard.
If this edition made you think of someone who keeps ending up with the bean vanilla, share it with them.
Share it with them.
If this landed in your inbox via a friend, you can subscribe to The Refusal of Default on Substack here.
Bad decisions rarely come from bad intentions. They come from a flawed process: too narrow a frame, too much attachment to the first option, too little space to genuinely evaluate.
A practical book that will change how you notice the moments your brain has already decided before you realised you were choosing.
Bye for now.
Siri 🌱🌀
P.S. If you would like to work with me, drop me an email at siri@sanerworklife.com and let's talk.
Being Sane is a weekly Sunday newsletter written for my coaching clients and shared as a gentle companion for reflection and self-study. It explores how we relate to work, effort, and ambition, and the small shifts that shape how we show up over time.
Hello friends, A question I keep returning to is one that is very personal to me: How do I know if I am being resilient in a given situation, or if I have simply succumbed to inertia? The journey of building something on your own is one of patience. Outcomes do not follow actions that linearly, and sometimes you do not even know when they are likely to arrive. This is very different from the corporate world I inhabited for nineteen years. Work hard or work smart, and in most cases you can see...
Hello friends, For the past three months, I have been trying to track my eating. Not calories, not macros. Just a simple daily log of what I ate, roughly how much, how stressed I was, and whether I moved my body that day. It sounds easy (theoretically). It is not. The mental effort of recalling a full day's food, combined with the discomfort of seeing how blindly I actually eat versus how I imagine I eat, means this habit has resisted every system I have thrown at it. I set reminders. I added...
Hello friends, The comments on last week's edition - Addition vs Subtraction: The Hidden Bias Keeping Your Plate Too Full - illustrated what I see constantly in coaching: knowing that boundaries are needed and actually putting them in place are worlds apart. One reader shared they had to work with the guilt of saying no with their therapist. Another said it's just so easy to keep adding, subtraction feels impossible. Both responses point to the same truth: boundaries are hard, even when we...